I saw this on the Nightly News last night. My 11 year old daughter was feeling a little clingy, so she sat there hugging me the whole time. I don't talk to my kids about my atheism. I have a sort of "prime directive" attitude about it. When they are ready, they will come to their own conclusions and whatever they choose will be OK with me as long as they remain respectful if others. But last night, I saw the gears turning in her head. The questions she asked me where very rational and reasoned. I was honest in my answers. A single tear fell from her eyes when she said that woman didn't have to die, much like the one when she lost her favorite teddy bear. Maybe not now, or even a decade from now, but st some point, I'm sure my daughter will embrace rationality.
So you don't believe in killing a criminal convicted of a heinous crime, but you do believe in killing a baby simply for having been conceived?
I have a somewhat colored view of situations like this in that the doctors told my mother prior to my birth, due to extreme complications, that they recommend she abort me. They said that in a best case scenario, she would die and I would suffer oxygen deprivation and never be "normal." I hate this situation because, first and foremost, it is a horrible situation. I hate it secondly because people will try to base policy around it - an extreme situation - instead of working to correct how extreme situations are handled. This was a bad deal.
Bolding mine. Ruling out (3) because they had to have recognized the infection and just chose to ignore it in trying to combine (1) and (2). If there is any justice, their implementation of (2) will earn them jail time under (1) and serve as a warning to other MDs to practice their own profession, not try to play pope or lawyer.
An update on this... It's been quite the political hot potato over the last number of months. The Catholic far-right have been very active in campaigning against it, but it looks likely that the government will legislate for some sort of very limited abortion over the next while. There's a public inquest into the event as well. The "Catholic country" comment is denied by the consultant, but admitted by a midwife. All sorts of other failings in her treatment have been identified too. http://www.breakingnews.ie/ireland/praveen-thanks-midwife-for-honesty-590930.html