Jennifer Connelly vs. Liv Tyler

Coming from the Hulk thread...



OR



Who was hotter at her prime, Jennifer Connelly or Liv Tyler? There is no 'teh baba' option, so if you don't have an opinion, beat it.

More photographic evidence to review is needed.

That is a hard fuckin' call, but I gotta go with Jennifer. She has the curves in all the right places.

Voting against Liv in a 'hot girl' poll just seems wrong, though. You need to put in an ugly third choice so that Liv is, like, not in last place, m'kay?

Don't get me wrong...

I definitely come down, uh, firmly on the Jennifer side of this one, but I would wear myself out on Liv given the chance.

Jennifer without a doubt

No contest.

Jennifer had teh boobies.

Kind of unfair as far as pictures though, because a flash of panty makes my heart all a flutter.

I'll still take Jennifer, though.

Jennifer:




Liv:

It's always been Jennifer for me. Ever since Labyrinth.

Not that I'd kick Liv out of bed, but it kinda skeeves me that she has her father's lips.

Jennifer. (what's this about prime?)

I've gotta go with Liv. Jennifer is hot, but I've never seen her in anything where I "wanted" her the way I wanted Liv after Empire Records or That thing you do.

I give you...
Exhibit A:

and Exhibit 2:

I would include a third, topless exhibit, but this isn't the White Room. No idear if it is a fake or not, but flip off the safeties on yer Google and search for "connelly career opportunities".

Very, very tough call.

Jennifer by a...nose?

Jennifer, no question. Liv's part chimp, and well, despite being much younger than Jennifer, hasn't aged nearly as well.

A real tough call would be between Jennifer and a long haired Milla Jovovich. IMHO, the only possible call in that situation would be to do both of them at the same time.

You can see Jen topless in "Requiem for a Dream" and one of her earlier films too (can't remember name). Quite lovely

Grrr. Torture is bad.

I pick Liv, just to even up the poll a bit.

Maybe by a nipple, but not by a nose. LOL

I believe Jen did have fake ones for a time, and her current sveltness is due to having them removed. I was a bit disappointed to hear that they were fake, but it doesn't take a bit away from her utterly stunning beauty.

Think he meant pre or post nose job.

liked her more before she was cut up.

Jen.

Nope. They were real. And she had breast reduction surgery. Personally I think she should be tried for crimes against humanity.

Ah, now I remember - she had them reduced because she wanted to be taken more seriously as an actress.

Personally I had no trouble taking her seriously AND lusting after teh boobies. She is quite exceptionally talented, IMHO.

Evidence:



Anyone seen Jennifer Connolly in Once Upon a Time in America? She was 14, and I felt quite guilty.

Her peak of hotness IMO - The Rocketeer

"We have liftoff" indeed

Regardless, she looks super

Connolly is hot but she's getting on a bit. Even at her peak I would still give it to Tyler. She's just flawless.

Definitely Jennifer!

Liv is just OK IMHO.

Liv Tyler is smokin' hot, no doubt about it.

But Jennifer Connelly is Whoa, mama! I vote for Jen.

Jennifer Connelly, based on the evidence in this thread.

Couple cup sizes more like.